Both quotes make sense to me. Sewell parts sells the 2006-2008 for $US305 (unpainted) without CL discount, and $US681 (painted) without CL discount. Hence, the the disparity between $380-odd and $950 quoted in this thread.
For those interest, Part #: 0815453831 for 06-08 and Part #: 0815453841 for 09-10